I was teaching a workshop a while back when one participant shared that she wanted to franchise her business. Nothing unusual about that on its own, until I discovered she hadn’t started the business yet. The business concept existed. The location didn’t. I asked her the obvious follow-up: what did franchising actually look like to her? She didn’t hesitate. Other people would run it. Other people would pay her to use her business concept. She was already picturing a version where the concept stayed hers and the work belonged to somebody else.
Her comment is a textbook example of the Dunning-Kruger effect, and it’s part of why I open most of my workshops with a short discussion of it. First-time entrepreneurs too often oversimplify what they’re actually trying to accomplish, and the same gap in understanding that produces the oversimplification is what keeps them from ever noticing it.
Her business goal resulted from commingling several tangentially related ideas without a real understanding of the underlying models. I’ve heard the “franchise as an expansion idea” often enough, from enough different people, that I don’t think it’s a one-off anymore, and it’s worth a deeper discussion of the underlying principles.
I have heard two settings of this general idea. There’s the owner who already has a business, one location, doing fine, who says that she wants to franchise, assuming it just means adding a few more locations. Same job, just with a bigger paycheck. Then there’s the person who is building a business model from scratch, picturing something closer to earning a royalty check that shows up because other people are using her idea and doing the actual work. They’re both wrong about what it actually costs to get there, confidently wrong, which might be the most telling part. Same mistake, just wearing two different outfits.
What actually changes when you go from one location to more than one isn’t more of the same job. It’s a completely different job, and almost nobody tells you that until you’re already several steps in. And the more I’ve sat with that workshop comment and reflected on similar previous discussions with other owners, the more I think the real confusion underneath it isn’t about franchising at all. It’s that most people never learned to see the difference between leadership and management, so they can’t recognize it operating right in front of them.
Leadership and Management, Before You Call Them CEO and President
Leadership is the design function. It decides what the business is, what it offers, and where it’s headed. Management, in contrast, is more about execution. It’s about running what’s already been designed. Almost nobody separates those two cleanly in their own head, especially when operating the business from one location, because there’s usually only one person doing both roles. But once you see them as two completely different roles, a lot of what follows gets much easier to see.
Related Post: What is the Difference Between Leadership and Management in Small Business?
From here on, I’m going to call leadership the CEO role and management the President role, because most businesses already use those words, even if they use them loosely.
Let’s begin with Robert Kiyosaki’s cash flow quadrant. He draws a clean distinction between being self-employed and owning a business. Self-employed, in his shorthand, looks a lot like being a freelancer: it’s your name, your decisions, and nobody else in the room when you make a decision. Own a real business, and it’s running based on a system and people rather than on you personally showing up every day.
Here’s the part worth being a bit more precise about. Two roles actually hide inside “business owner.” In most small businesses that operate out of a single location, the owner holds both, and no one ever notices they’re separate. A franchise owner is the cleanest illustration.
A franchisee functionally acts as the President. They execute what they received from someone else: the recipes, the systems, the brand standards, and the training. They didn’t invent any of that. Their role is to run it well. Even once they own their own outcome, and we’ll get to what that actually means, that’s still management, not leadership.
The design function stays with the franchisor. The franchisor acts like the CEO. They focus on the outside world, decide what to add or cut from what the business offers, and are responsible for keeping the brand and the training documents solid enough for every franchisee to build on. In bigger, more formal companies, that design function actually flows from a board, to the CEO, to the President, but that’s a piece for another day, worth naming once and leaving there.
President is execution. CEO is vision.
Now here’s an important clarification I want to make sure doesn’t get lost: that split isn’t something that only shows up once you scale. Plenty of single-location owners already run it, without the vocabulary. You hire a general manager, hand them the day-to-day, and you personally keep working on vision, marketing, and where the money goes. You’re already splitting the President and CEO roles between two people, or at least two hats, at one location. I’ve written about this tension before: the Technician, the President, and the CEO all pulling at the same owner’s attention in Anatomy of a Business Owner. That piece is really about how hard it is to hold all three roles inside one person. What it doesn’t cover, on purpose, is what happens once those roles can no longer live inside one person’s calendar. That’s what changes here.
The Actual Leap: One CEO, Many Presidents
So, if the split between President and CEO isn’t new, what actually is? Scope.
One location only ever needs one President function, no matter who holds it, or whether anyone holds it deliberately at all. Open a second location, and the President function has to multiply: each site needs someone exercising it, responsible for exactly that site and nothing else, whether that’s a dedicated person at each address or one person covering more than one. The CEO function doesn’t multiply the same way. That’s structural, not a matter of style or personal preference. For example, Coca-Cola runs a whole roster of regional Presidents under a single CEO, and that’s not an accident of org-chart taste. It’s what happens anywhere the operating unit multiplies and the vision-and-brand function doesn’t.
Related Post: CEO vs President – You Need to Know That Their Roles Are Different
Picture a one-location drywall company. You hang the sheet yourself, or close to it. You run the crew. You do your own local marketing, because you know your own town. You’re the President and the CEO, and honestly it barely matters which hat you’re wearing at any given moment, because there’s only one truck, one crew, one set of walls to worry about.
Open a second location in another city or across town, and the President job clones itself. Someone else now runs that site’s crew, schedule, and daily decisions. But there’s still only one of you, acting as the CEO, looking at the whole business from the outside, deciding whether drywall’s even the right thing to keep doing, watching where the industry’s headed, and increasingly, holding the only copy of “how we actually do business” that both locations are supposed to be using to run the location.
And there’s a second problem hiding underneath the first one: you can no longer trust your own gut the way you used to. When you operate only one location, you’re close enough to the work that your decisions and their results form a tight feedback loop: you try something, you see what happens, you adjust. Open a second location, even one across town, and that feedback loop gets muddier. Different neighborhoods read the same offer differently. A promotion that works in one part of town can flop in another for reasons that have nothing to do with how well anybody executed it. You can’t stand in both places and read the signal yourself anymore.
The Fork: Hire, or Franchise
Distance alone, the problem from the last section, raises a real question about command and control versus commander’s intent; more on that in a moment. But underneath that there’s a separate, deeper choice about how the President relationship itself gets built: hire, or let them buy in. It’s not a simple binary either. One side of that fork carries a lot more depth than the other.
Path one: you keep ownership, and you hire. You fund the new location, you own it, and you bring in a President to run it. You’ve got several options in how you compensate them: straight salary, or salary plus a bonus tied to how that location performs. Either way, it’s still command-and-control underneath. You own the asset, you carry the downside if it fails, and you can direct, or replace, that President largely at will. It’s worth being blunt about what a bonus actually buys you here: upside-aligned incentive, not downside-aligned risk. There’s no downside for them. Just a missed bonus. Incentive without risk.
My son Josh was a shop foreman at an auto repair business that got acquired a while back. The new ownership put in a bonus structure tied to store performance, real incentive, genuinely tied to results, no capital of his own at risk, no ownership. But the thresholds were set so far out that most people couldn’t reach them. The carrot existed on paper. In practice, it didn’t work, and the shop lost several key people over it, including my son. That’s path one’s other failure mode: the incentive can be real and still not enough, because someone else decides how far away to put it.
Path two: you let the President buy in. Franchise, or franchise-like: the President funds the build-out of the location with their own capital, owns the outcome, and pays you a fee to open plus an ongoing royalty as they run it. That fee and royalty aren’t buying permission to use your name. They’re buying the business in a box, the model you already built and already proved works, the systems, the training, the playbook for every mistake you already made so they don’t have to make it themselves. That’s what the ongoing royalty is actually funding, not a logo, a working system. That’s a different kind of relationship than hiring somebody. It’s closer to marrying them into the business, both your fortunes genuinely tied together from that point forward. Incentive with real downside attached, because now it’s their downside too. And this is the path that actually gets closest to what my workshop participant may have been picturing all along: other people running it, funded by their own stake, paying her as they go.
At one location, you can get away with running things like a benevolent dictator, and it’s not a personality flaw that you do; it’s just what proximity makes cheap. If something’s off, you walk over and fix it, or show somebody the right way with your own hands. Command and control works when you’re close enough to verify and correct almost anything nearby, and it stays fully available to you on path one, at any size; hiring never takes it off the table. It just runs straight into the broken feedback-loop problem from a moment ago as you add locations. That’s the real line between the two paths. It’s not whether command and control still works well at a distance. It usually doesn’t. What matters is whether you still hold the lever at all. On path one, the lever stays in your hand even when it’s painful to use. On path two, ownership takes it out of your hand entirely.
Path two is different in kind, not just in generosity. What replaces command and control there is something the military actually has a name for: commander’s intent. A commanding officer holding territory he can’t personally stand in doesn’t try to issue orders for every situation that might come up. He states the reasoning and the outcome he’s after, clearly enough that the people executing it, at a distance, in conditions he never personally experiences, can make the call he would have made if he’d been standing right there. Ownership is what makes that fully necessary rather than optional. Once a President owns the outcome, you, as the CEO, have largely given up the ability to command and control them. You’re relying on shared understanding, and their own stake, to do the rest of the work a document alone can’t.
Machiavelli ran into the same problem centuries earlier: his advice, in The Prince, to a ruler who couldn’t personally occupy a distant territory was never “send more soldiers.” It was to make sure the people governing in his place understood his intent well enough to act on it whether he was watching or not. Commander’s intent, before there was a name for it.
Both paths run into the same wall from here. What actually has to make that crossing isn’t a rule you can hand somebody. It’s judgment, and that’s a harder thing to transfer than either path lets on.
Knowledge Versus Wisdom: What You’re Actually Training
Here’s where a standard operating procedure starts to show its limits, on either path. An SOP is genuinely good at one thing: telling somebody how to do a specific task correctly. Fold it this way, hang the sheet like this, greet the customer with this line. It’s a fine tool for training the person actually doing the work.
But what you’re handing a President isn’t a task. It’s judgment. Aristotle had two different words for this, and they’re worth stealing: technē, the craft-knowledge of how to make or do a thing correctly, and phronesis, practical wisdom, the judgment to act well in a specific situation that no rule fully covers. An apprentice needs technē. A President needs phronesis, and no SOP, no matter how thorough, actually transfers that. What transfers it is explaining your reasoning clearly enough, and consistently enough, that somebody else can reproduce your judgment without you standing next to them.
A while ago I wrote about the old stonemason’s lodge, apprentice, journeyman, master, as an intergenerational system for passing down exactly this kind of judgment (see AI Is Your Portland Cement). The apprentice learns technique from direct correction, someone standing over their shoulder fixing their grip on the chisel. The master, though, isn’t doing that anymore. The master is training the journeyman, the one who’ll go on to train the next apprentice, and what passes between master and journeyman is closer to the reasoning behind the whole cathedral’s design than it is to any single stone. That’s the rung you’re climbing when you go from training workers to training managers. You’ve stopped correcting technique. You’re transferring judgment, one level removed from where the actual work happens.
My son’s acquisition story from a moment ago fits here too: the mechanics never got retrained on how to fix cars; only the store’s managers had to internalize the new architecture sitting on top of that work, the pay structure, the HR structure, the billing system. Same pattern: judgment and structure changing hands at the management level while the technical work underneath stays exactly the same.
What You’re Actually Funding
Many people initially think a franchise royalty works like rent: invest upfront, then collect passive income. It isn’t. It’s payment for someone to write that transferable judgment down initially, then keep it current forever, because markets shift and what worked last year quietly stops working. This is close to what I think my workshop participant was actually picturing: set the system up once, then sit back and collect a check while it runs itself. I want to be clear about something here too: I’ve had clients come to me thinking almost exactly this, that a franchise means building it once and then stepping back while the checks show up. It doesn’t take long for them to understand what that royalty is actually paying for. Once they do, they understand a franchise isn’t passive income for the franchisor. The shape of the mistake remains even when nobody says it out loud: mistaking “I built a system other people can run” for “I built a system that doesn’t need me anymore.” Those aren’t the same thing.
The ad fund requirement in most franchise agreements is probably one of the clearest places to see the President-and-CEO split in action, not just as a concept. The franchisor dictates the local ad spend, sets the brand, and hands down a general guidance document for how marketing’s supposed to work. But adjusting that spend to local conditions, what actually works in this particular market, is a President-level decision, because the President is the one standing closer to that local market. This is the feedback loop from a few sections back, paying off directly. The CEO can’t read the local signal from a distance. So, the CEO’s real job is building a framework precise enough that the President can make the call the CEO would have made sitting right there, adjusted for conditions the CEO will never personally experience. Commander’s intent, just smaller and more specific.
Control over the ad fund is just one example. Another cost has nothing to do with marketing dollars: writing down what worked well enough that someone else can run it, and keeping that write-up current as things change.
That same cost doesn’t only show up inside a franchise. It shows up anywhere a business expands to a second location, whether or not anyone calls it franchising. A mom-and-pop restaurant opening its second location, a dental practice opening a second office: they’re taking on that cost too. The difference is nobody’s holding them to it. A franchisor collects a royalty precisely because they’re on the hook to keep earning it: the system has to stay worth paying for, month after month, or franchisees have every right to ask what they’re actually buying. Outside a franchise, there’s no ongoing obligation forcing that work to happen, so it’s easy to skip. Nobody sits down and writes the playbook, because nothing is making them. That’s a big part of why so many second locations quietly underperform: the owner assumed the same instincts that worked at location one would carry over to the second, and nothing forced anyone to check.
There’s a governance question underneath all of this too, worth naming directly: what stays locked to protect the brand and the standard, and what a President actually gets to decide on their own. The ad fund answer is just one example. What actually answers this question, across every example like it, is the framework itself.
And if you’re the CEO in this picture, actually sitting down to build that document, the framework a President can run on without you standing there, that’s not a metaphorical exercise. It’s the same discipline I’ve written about elsewhere as Bones, Muscles, and the Harness. Bones represent the structural definitions: what a customer is, what a job is, named the same way everywhere. Muscles, in contrast, are the actual decision rules, the kind you get from working through something like the Iceberg Model, a Stock and Flow Diagram, or a Causal Loop Diagram, until a real judgment call turns into something repeatable. The harness is commander’s intent and guardrails, and you already saw it a few paragraphs back: precise enough that the President can adjust something like local ad spend on their own and land close to the call the CEO would have made without checking in first. That’s not future work you get to put off. That’s the job description the moment you open location two.
If you’re building toward this seriously, from either direction- already running one location and eyeing a second, or building something from scratch with a franchising model in mind- there’s real, practical groundwork worth reading next: what it actually takes to build a franchise system (see What It Takes to Franchise a Successful Business Model), and the risks nobody warns you about before opening a second location, franchised or not (see Expansion Challenge). This piece is the part before those, the part where you figure out what you’re actually signing up to become.
Back to that workshop room. The instinct that got my franchise-curious participant into the room in the first place wasn’t unexpected. I’ve heard it before. Wanting to build something bigger than what you can personally carry is a good instinct, maybe one of the better ones in the room. The honest version isn’t “a business that runs without me.” She wasn’t trying to remove herself from the business. She was trying to remove herself from the decisions that shouldn’t need her at all, so she could get much better at the ones that still do. It’s “I’m willing to become the kind of owner whose only remaining tool is the framework itself: the bones that define what a customer is and what a job is, the muscles that turn judgment into a repeatable rule, the harness that lets someone else run on all of it without me standing there. Not my own hands on the work anymore. And if I choose the harder path, somebody else’s own stake in getting it right, too.” That’s a harder thing to want. It’s also the only version of it that’s actually true. The CEO’s job becomes vision. The President’s job becomes execution. Neither one goes away. They just stop living inside the same person.
Being both CEO and President keeps you close to the one thing you can’t outsource: the feedback loop. Dividing the two roles trades that closeness for scale, but only if you’ve actually built the architecture, the bones, the muscles, the harness, precise enough to carry your judgment without you standing there.
Which one are you actually prepared to do?









